We had a significant amount of code for handling what seemed to be 2
cases, but which were really just a single case (if we are trying to
narrow to a specific message ID, and we end up landing on it, restore
the previous offset; with the special case that the previous offset
might be passed in from the previous call).
This cleanup also fixes a very minor bug, where our background
auto-reload (`reload.initiate({immediate: true});` in the JS console)
would incorrectly reset the pointer position to match the a near:
message ID if that was present in the narrow.
This commit fixes a couple regression related to narrowing.
For a long time we've had bugs where we too aggressively
preserve the currrent selection on topic -> stream
re-narrows ("s" key) even when the wider narrow may
have unread messages before the selection.
Also, we recently introduced a bug so that when you used
a link from the "copy link to conversation" (aka a "near"
query), it would advance you to your first unread message
despite the near:999 specifier. (The code would work for
subsequent "near" queries once you had fetched some of
your original messages).
This commit introduces a new data structure called id_info (replacing
the select_strategy data structure) in various functions and uses that
to track all the ids of relevance.
Significantly rewritten by tabbott to handle a few extra corner cases,
and add a ton of comments explaining why it works the way it does.
Fixes#2091.
Fixes#9606.
The "if" condition that was removed in this commit
is no longer needed, since the called code now
handles the cannot-apply-locally use case. (We
wanted the called functions to be defensive, so
they already were effectively handling the conditions
anyway, and recent commits has them returning
appropriate values and doing the right things.)
We had debug code that was reaching into msg_list._items when
it could use msg_list.all_messages() instead.
When we split out MessageListData, using _items started
breaking this code.
We now work with MessageListData objects while populating
data from local narrows, before actually making the
wrapper MessageList object.
This change will simplify unit testing (less view stuff
to fake out) in certain situations.
It will also allow us to eliminate the delay_render flag.
We used to have positional parameters for table_name
and filter, but we don't use them for message_list.all
and we're about to replace filter in some cases.
Passing everything in on opts is more consistent and
self-documenting in the calling code, plus lots of
unit tests can get away with passing in `{}` now
for situations where table_name does not matter.
All of our callers pass in muting_enabled, so we
remove the default value for it. And then the
collapse_messages variable doesn't have to live on
`this` as it's only being passed through down to the
view.
We now only preserve the offset for the previous
selection (pre-narrow) if that is still the id
we want selected after calling maybe_add_local_messages.
Right not this does not change any behavior, but
upcoming changes to maybe_add_local_messages will
change the selected id to the first unread message
in certain circumstances, in which case preserving
the offset will possibly be confusing, since you're
not on the same message.
This is preparation for enabling an eslint indentation configuration.
90% of these changes are just fixes for indentation errors that have
snuck into the codebase over the years; the others are more
significant reformatting to make eslint happy (that are not otherwise
actually improvements).
The one area that we do not attempt to work on here is the
"switch/case" indentation.
For a commit that was just merged I had the "back-out" case
at the wrong nesting level. It was a pretty obscure failure
scenario that never came up in practice, but basically if you
were starting at a message that was not in your narrow, but
we did have some messages in your narrow, we would try to
go near the old message instead of talking to the server to
find the next unread message in that narrow.
Barring a few minor edge cases, when we now do a narrow
that is based on a sidebar-like search (e.g. stream/topic,
no extra conditions), we now go directly to either the
first unread message we know about locally or the last
message if we're all caught up.
We of course used to do this in master until recently; this behavior
was broken by Tim's narrowing refactor branch (ending with
26ac1d237b) which moved us to always
using the select_first_unread flag, by default (fixing issues where if
you clicked around while your pointer was behind, you'd land in the
wrong place).
We now have arguably the best of both worlds:
* The pointer is not considered when computing narrowing positioning
* We only go to the server for sidebar clicks if the data isn't
available in the browser.
This is purely to make it easier to read narrow.activate()
without having to page past lots of unnecessary detail when
you're trying to understand things like how we set the
selection.
The maybe_select_closest helper, when first introduced, was
tiny and close to its callers.
As it's grown, it's become kind of a big hurdle to reading
narrow.activate(), because it's out of chronological order
and it's hard to tell at a glance which variables it's closing
on.
Now we just move it out to module scope.
It's mostly moving code, with these minor changes:
* we pass in opts for the old closure vars
* we rename then_select_offset -> select_offset
* we early-exit on empty lists
We replace these variables in narrow.activate:
then_select_id (int w/-1 as a sentinel)
select_first_unread (boolean)
The main goal here is to get away from the boolean, since
we are about to introduce a third select strategy.
The new var is select_strategy and it has a union
type with these flavors:
"exact" (was select_first_unread === false)
"first_unread" (was select_first_unread === true)
The new flavor will be something like "last_id".
Eliminating then_select_id is also nice, since the -1
sentinel value could be a pitfall, and it's semantically
cleaner to encapsulate behind a check for
select_strategy.flavor.
We use an IIFE (immediately invoked function expression)
to fetch messages. This will allow us to introduce some
local vars in a subsequent commit without creating an ugly
diff and without cluttering an already crowded namespace.
This cleans up a subsequent diff. Within the context of
`maybe_select_closest`, there's only one `msg_id` we care about,
so the more convoluted name `then_select_id` makes much less
sense than it does in the enclosing scope, and it will make
even less sense after some future changes.
There's also some cosmetic cleanup here.
When we are deciding whether to preserve scroll position, we
mainly care that then_select_offset is set to a value. If
we had no intention of preserving scroll offset, we would have
never bothered to set it. The check for !select_first_unread
is always redundant, as verified by lots of clicking around
with some print debugging. And it's a brittle check,
because it couples the decision of scrolling destination to
the mechanism by which we decide our selection. While those
things are closely related, it's possible in the future that
we'll decide to advance to an unread message and still want
to set then_select_offset, but we might forget to mutate
select_first_unread.
Long story short, the code is simpler and safer now.
We move the var declaration of then_select_offset closer to
where it gets calculated, and we avoid code duplication in
calling current_msg_list.get_row().
Even when then_select_id has the sentinel value of -1, we were
trying to look it up in our message_list.all object. This would
have returned undefined, which is fine, but it's more explicit
to just bypass the check.
This mostly sets up the next commit. The two conditions here
are both inexpensive to check, but we want to bypass an upcoming
expensive operation if can_apply_locally() returns false.
We consistently either pass a `then_select_id` into narrow.activate,
or were using the select_first_unread option. Now, we just compute
select_first_unread based on the value of then_select_id.
In the very early days of Zulip, we didn't have unread counts; just
the pointer, and the correct behavior when opening a new tab was to
place you near the pointer. That doesn't make any sense now that we
do have unread counts, and this corner case has been a wart for a long
time.
This commit does the main behavior change here. However, there's a
bug we need to fix, where we might end up trying to pre-render a view
of the narrow based on the `all_msg_list` data before `all_msg_list`
is caught up). We need to fix that bug before we can merge this; it
should be possible to determine that using `FetchStatus` on
`all_msg_list`, or with better performance by using the `unread_msgs`
structure to determine whether the message we should be selecting is
present locally.
Fixes#789.
Fixes#9070.
Apparently, we were incorrectly passing through something related to
opts.use_initial_narrow_pointer as the value for `use_first_anchor`.
If you read the logic in narrow.js carefully,
use_initial_narrow_pointer was unconditionally false.
The correct value for this attribute is when we're trying to narrow to
the first unread message in a given context. There are two things to
check:
* then_select_id is -1; i.e. we don't have a specific message ID we're
trying to narrow around.
* select_first_unread is True, i.e. we're trying to narrow to the
first unread message.
A bit more work should allow us to get rid of the second condition,
but I'm not quite confident enough to do that yet.
The refactor in 12509515ae had a subtle
bug, which is that we switched from accessing the message list "this"
(aka the message list being rerendered) to current_msg_list. This
meant that when the narrowed_msg_list was in view and code needed to
modify home_msg_list, we accessed the wrong `selected_row` to preserve
the scroll position of (namely, the one in current_msg_list, not the
one in home_msg_list).
Fix this, by moving the function to be a property of the
message_list_view object, which makes more sense structurally, anyway.
We may, in the future, want to do a similar migration for more of
message_viewport.js.
Fixes#8854.
Fixes#8965.
Mark_message(s)_as_read is used in marking a message as having been
read by the browser, rename it to notify_server_message(s)_read to
avoid any confusion.
Previously, when unnarrowing, we were calling this on the wrong
selector (this was missed years ago when we refactored Zulip to use
divs rather than table rows in the main message feed).
Noticed while debugging #5312.
We now attach a fetch_status to message lists, so that they
can track their fetch status individually. When you go
back in a narrow and get all the older messages, we turn
off future fetches.
The narrow.js code no longer needs to orchestrate anything
here. The "home" message list won't have as many redundant
fetches after this commit, because we don't need to reset
flags every time we do `narrow.deactivate`.
And then actual narrows get a new message list every time
you narrow, so their fetch status gets reset implicitly
as part of constructing the MessageList object.
We are going to remove message_fetch.reset_for_narrow() soon,
but its callers probably still want to hide any scrolling
indicators, and we just let them do that directly.
This helps us consolidate the fetching constants without
having to export them. It will also remove some
responsibility for narrow.js to track fetching state.
This mostly moves code from ui.js.
We change the arguments to `message_fetch.load_more_messages()`
to be `opts` with callbacks for `show_loading` and `hide_loading`.
We also defer starting the scroll handler until `message_fetch.js`
has been initialized.
This works simimlar to the "n" key for next topics.
This commit does a few things:
* It wires up the hotkey to an existing function
that could change narrows.
* It adds documentation.
* It adds logic to make sure the compose box does
not open.
@showell helped a bit with the wording of comments here.
Fixes#4874
This commit prefixes stream names in urls with stream ids,
so that the urls don't break when we rename streams.
strean name: foo bar.com%
before: #narrow/stream/foo.20bar.2Ecom.25
after: #narrow/stream/20-foo-bar.2Ecom.25
For new realms, everything is simple under the new scheme, since
we just parse out the stream id every time to figure out where
to narrow.
For old realms, any old URLs will still work under the new scheme,
assuming the stream hasn't been renamed (and of course old urls
wouldn't have survived stream renaming in the first place). The one
exception is the hopefully rare case of a stream name starting with
something like "99-" and colliding with another stream whose id is 99.
The way that we enocde the stream name portion of the URL is kind
of unimportant now, since we really only look at the stream id, but
we still want a safe encoding of the name that is mostly human
readable, so we now convert spaces to dashes in the stream name. Also,
we try to ensure more code on both sides (frontend and backend) calls
common functions to do the encoding.
Fixes#4713
This helper function will allow us to cycle through PM narrows
that are unread, once we map it to a hotkey and/or other UI.
(We intend to make something like the "n" key for topics, but
that works on PM narrows instead.)
We made this change because users often unnecessarily click "Home"
first in their use of Zulip, because it seems appealing. While "All
messages" isn't quite precise (it doesn't include muted streams), it
does describe relatively simply the interleaved view that this
represents.
This commit leaves everything as "home" in the code, and only changes
user-visible strings and docs. Changing the code will be a big project;
there are hundreds of relevant occurrences in variable names, etc.
Further, we'll probably want to convert those various variable names
in different ways.
Tweaked by tabbott to extend the commit message and update a few comments.
Tim Abbott
Steve Howell
Shubham Dhama
Shubham Padia
Abhigyan Khaund
YJDave
Rishi Gupta
Alena Volkova
Cory Lynch