The Content-Type, Content-Disposition, StorageClass, and general
metadata are not set according to our patterns by tusd; copy the file
to itself to update those properties.
Setting `ResponseContentDisposition=attachment` means that we override
the stored `ContentDisposition`, which includes a filename. This
means that using the "Download" link on servers with S3 storage
produced a file named the sanitized version we stored.
Explicitly build a `ContentDisposition` to tell S3 to return, which
includes both `attachment` as well as the filename (if we have it
locally).
This allows finer-grained access control and auditing. The links
generated also expire after one week, and the suggested configuration
is that the underlying data does as well.
Co-authored-by: Prakhar Pratyush <prakhar@zulip.com>
The `get_signed_upload_url` code is called for every S3 file serve
request, and is thus in the hot path. The boto3 client caching
optimization is thus potentially useful as a performance optimization.
We may not always have trivial access to all of the bytes of the
uploaded file -- for instance, if the file was uploaded previously, or
by some other process. Downloading the entire image in order to check
its headers is an inefficient use of time and bandwidth.
Adjust `maybe_thumbnail` and dependencies to potentially take a
`pyvips.Source` which supports streaming data from S3 or disk. This
allows making the ImageAttachment row, if deemed appropriate, based on
only a few KB of data, and not the entire image.
A new table is created to track which path_id attachments are images,
and for those their metadata, and which thumbnails have been created.
Using path_id as the effective primary key lets us ignore if the
attachment is archived or not, saving some foreign key messes.
A new worker is added to observe events when rows are added to this
table, and to generate and store thumbnails for those images in
differing sizes and formats.
Hash the salt, user-id, and now avatar version into the filename.
This allows the URL contents to be immutable, and thus to be marked as
immutable and cacheable. Since avatars are served unauthenticated,
hashing with a server-side salt makes the current and past avatars not
enumerable.
This requires plumbing the current (or future) avatar version through
various parts of the upload process.
Since this already requires a full migration of current avatars, also
take the opportunity to fix the missing `.png` on S3 uploads (#12852).
We switch from SHA-1 to SHA-256, but truncate it such that avatar URL
data does not substantially increase in size.
Fixes: #12852.
boto3 has two different modalities of making API calls -- through
resources, and through clients. Resources are a higher-level
abstraction, and thus more generally useful, but some APIs are only
accessible through clients. It is possible to get to a client object
from a resource, but not vice versa.
Use `get_bucket(...).meta.client` when we need direct access to the
client object for more complex API calls; this lets all of the
configuration for how to access S3 to sit within `get_bucket`. Client
objects are not bound to only one bucket, but we get to them based on
the bucket we will be interacting with, for clarity.
We removed the cached session object, as it serves no real purpose.
e883ab057f started caching the boto client, which we had identified
as slow call. e883ab057f went further, calling
`get_boto_client().generate_presigned_url()` once and caching that
result.
This makes the inner cache on the client useless. Remove it.
Uploads are well-positioned to use S3's "intelligent tiering" storage
class. Add a setting to let uploaded files to declare their desired
storage class at upload time, and document how to move existing files
to the same storage class.
Actions like deleting realms may leave unreferenced uploads in the
attachment storage backend.
Fix these by walking the complete contents of the attachment storage
backend, and removing files which are no longer present in the
database. This may take quite some time, as it is necessarily O(n) in
the number of files uploaded to the system.
The Content-Type of user-provided uploads was provided by the browser
at initial upload time, and stored in S3; however, 04cf68b45e
switched to determining the Content-Disposition merely from the
filename. This makes uploads vulnerable to a stored XSS, wherein a
file uploaded with a content-type of `text/html` and an extension of
`.png` would be served to browsers as `Content-Disposition: inline`,
which is unsafe.
The `Content-Security-Policy` headers in the previous commit mitigate
this, but only for browsers which support them.
Revert parts of 04cf68b45e, specifically by allowing S3 to provide
the Content-Disposition header, and using the
`ResponseContentDisposition` argument when necessary to override it to
`attachment`. Because we expect S3 responses to vary based on this
argument, we include it in the cache key; since the query parameter
has dashes in it, we can't use use the helper `$arg_` variables, and
must parse it from the query parameters manually.
Adding the disposition may decrease the cache hit rate somewhat, but
downloads are infrequent enough that it is unlikely to have a
noticeable effect. We take care to not adjust the cache key for
requests which do not specify the disposition.
When file uploads are stored in S3, this means that Zulip serves as a
302 to S3. Because browsers do not cache redirects, this means that
no image contents can be cached -- and upon every page load or reload,
every recently-posted image must be re-fetched. This incurs extra
load on the Zulip server, as well as potentially excessive bandwidth
usage from S3, and on the client's connection.
Switch to fetching the content from S3 in nginx, and serving the
content from nginx. These have `Cache-control: private, immutable`
headers set on the response, allowing browsers to cache them locally.
Because nginx fetching from S3 can be slow, and requests for uploads
will generally be bunched around when a message containing them are
first posted, we instruct nginx to cache the contents locally. This
is safe because uploaded file contents are immutable; access control
is still mediated by Django. The nginx cache key is the URL without
query parameters, as those parameters include a time-limited signed
authentication parameter which lets nginx fetch the non-public file.
This adds a number of nginx-level configuration parameters to control
the caching which nginx performs, including the amount of in-memory
index for he cache, the maximum storage of the cache on disk, and how
long data is retained in the cache. The currently-chosen figures are
reasonable for small to medium deployments.
The most notable effect of this change is in allowing browsers to
cache uploaded image content; however, while there will be many fewer
requests, it also has an improvement on request latency. The
following tests were done with a non-AWS client in SFO, a server and
S3 storage in us-east-1, and with 100 requests after 10 requests of
warm-up (to fill the nginx cache). The mean and standard deviation
are shown.
| | Redirect to S3 | Caching proxy, hot | Caching proxy, cold |
| ----------------- | ------------------- | ------------------- | ------------------- |
| Time in Django | 263.0 ms ± 28.3 ms | 258.0 ms ± 12.3 ms | 258.0 ms ± 12.3 ms |
| Small file (842b) | 586.1 ms ± 21.1 ms | 266.1 ms ± 67.4 ms | 288.6 ms ± 17.7 ms |
| Large file (660k) | 959.6 ms ± 137.9 ms | 609.5 ms ± 13.0 ms | 648.1 ms ± 43.2 ms |
The hot-cache performance is faster for both large and small files,
since it saves the client the time having to make a second request to
a separate host. This performance improvement remains at least 100ms
even if the client is on the same coast as the server.
Cold nginx caches are only slightly slower than hot caches, because
VPC access to S3 endpoints is extremely fast (assuming it is in the
same region as the host), and nginx can pool connections to S3 and
reuse them.
However, all of the 648ms taken to serve a cold-cache large file is
occupied in nginx, as opposed to the only 263ms which was spent in
nginx when using redirects to S3. This means that to overall spend
less time responding to uploaded-file requests in nginx, clients will
need to find files in their local cache, and skip making an
uploaded-file request, at least 60% of the time. Modeling shows a
reduction in the number of client requests by about 70% - 80%.
The `Content-Disposition` header logic can now also be entirely shared
with the local-file codepath, as can the `url_only` path used by
mobile clients. While we could provide the direct-to-S3 temporary
signed URL to mobile clients, we choose to provide the
served-from-Zulip signed URL, to better control caching headers on it,
and greater consistency. In doing so, we adjust the salt used for the
URL; since these URLs are only valid for 60s, the effect of this salt
change is minimal.
Alex Vandiver
Anders Kaseorg