diff --git a/web/src/compose_actions.ts b/web/src/compose_actions.ts
index 4b5a7f3136..824301f951 100644
--- a/web/src/compose_actions.ts
+++ b/web/src/compose_actions.ts
@@ -328,9 +328,19 @@ export let start = (raw_opts: ComposeActionsStartOpts): void => {
     if (opts.message_type === "private") {
         compose_state.set_compose_recipient_id(compose_state.DIRECT_MESSAGE_ID);
         compose_recipient.on_compose_select_recipient_update();
-    } else if (opts.stream_id) {
+    } else if (opts.stream_id && opts.topic) {
         compose_state.set_stream_id(opts.stream_id);
-        compose_recipient.on_compose_select_recipient_update();
+    } else if (opts.stream_id) {
+        const stream = stream_data.get_sub_by_id(opts.stream_id);
+        if (stream && stream_data.can_post_messages_in_stream(stream)) {
+            compose_state.set_stream_id(opts.stream_id);
+            compose_recipient.on_compose_select_recipient_update();
+        } else {
+            opts.stream_id = undefined;
+            compose_state.set_stream_id("");
+            opts.topic = "";
+            compose_recipient.open_compose_recipient_dropdown();
+        }
     } else {
         // Open stream selection dropdown if no stream is selected.
         compose_state.set_stream_id("");
diff --git a/web/tests/compose_actions.test.cjs b/web/tests/compose_actions.test.cjs
index 242a128299..2e7b1edc4e 100644
--- a/web/tests/compose_actions.test.cjs
+++ b/web/tests/compose_actions.test.cjs
@@ -142,6 +142,7 @@ test("start", ({override, override_rewire, mock_template}) => {
     override_rewire(compose_actions, "clear_textarea", noop);
     override_rewire(compose_recipient, "on_compose_select_recipient_update", noop);
     override_rewire(compose_recipient, "check_posting_policy_for_compose_box", noop);
+    override_rewire(stream_data, "can_post_messages_in_stream", () => true);
     mock_template("inline_decorated_stream_name.hbs", false, noop);
 
     let compose_defaults;
@@ -333,7 +334,6 @@ test("respond_to_message", ({override, override_rewire, mock_template}) => {
 test("reply_with_mention", ({override, override_rewire, mock_template}) => {
     mock_banners();
     compose_state.set_message_type("stream");
-    override_rewire(compose_recipient, "on_compose_select_recipient_update", noop);
     override_rewire(compose_actions, "complete_starting_tasks", noop);
     override_rewire(compose_actions, "clear_textarea", noop);
     override_private_message_recipient({override});